How Negligence Per Se Can Affect a Kentucky Car Accident Claim

Home  /  Blog  /  How Negligence Per Se Can Affect a Kentucky Car Accident Claim
How Negligence Per Se Can Affect a Kentucky Car Accident Claim
  |    |  
Last Modified on Oct 26, 2026

How Negligence Per Se Can Affect a Kentucky Car Accident Claim

A driver ran a red light and hit you. Now an insurance adjuster is asking who caused the crash. That’s stressful, especially with medical bills and a damaged car to deal with.

Negligence per se is a legal rule that can help in a situation like this. In Kentucky, a driver may be seen as careless just for breaking a safety law, if that broken law helped cause the crash. It doesn’t settle your whole claim, but it can give the fault question a clearer starting point.

The Schafer Law Office has represented injured people in Louisville for more than 30 years. If you’d like to talk through what happened, you can ask about a free consultation.

What You Need to Know

  • Negligence per se can apply when a driver breaks a Kentucky safety law and that helps cause a crash.
  • The law that was broken has to protect people like you and aim at the kind of harm you suffered.
  • A broken law speaks to carelessness. It doesn’t prove how badly you were hurt.
  • Kentucky’s shared fault rules may reduce what you recover without automatically ending your claim.
  • Police reports, photos, and medical records tend to matter early.

If you already have a police report or a ticket, The Schafer Law Office in Louisville can look it over with you.

What Is Negligence Per Se in a Kentucky Car Accident Case?

Negligence per se means a driver can be treated as careless because that driver broke a safety law. Normally, an injured person has to show the other driver failed to use reasonable care. When a state traffic law was broken, the law itself can fill in that step. Kentucky’s version comes from KRS 446.070 in the Kentucky Revised Statutes. It says a person hurt when someone breaks a state law may seek damages from that person. The focus is on what the driver did, not what the driver meant to do. Think of it as a shortcut for proving one piece of the claim, the carelessness piece. Whether it fits your crash depends on which law was broken and how it ties to your injuries.

Which Traffic Violations Can Support a Negligence Per Se Claim?

Several common driving mistakes can involve a broken state traffic law.

Each of these rules exists to keep other people on the road safe. Whether one of them applies to your crash depends on the facts. The police report is often the first place those facts show up.

What Does Kentucky Law Require Before a Violation Counts?

A broken law has to pass three tests before it supports a negligence per se claim. Kentucky courts have described them in cases going back decades, and each one is about connecting the rule to your crash.

The Law Must Protect People Like You

Traffic laws are usually written to protect other drivers, passengers, pedestrians, and cyclists. A law that tells drivers to stop at a red light, for example, protects everyone crossing that intersection. If you were in one of those groups, this test is often easy to meet.

The Law Must Aim at This Kind of Harm

A red light law exists to prevent intersection crashes. A rule about paperwork, like an expired tag, usually has little to do with how a crash happened. It may not help your claim.

The Violation Must Help Cause Your Injury

Courts ask whether the broken law was a substantial factor in causing the harm. Picture a driver with a broken taillight who hits you at noon. The taillight likely had nothing to do with the crash. A jury decides what caused what, so the details of your case carry a lot of weight.

If you’re not sure a traffic law played a part in your crash, The Schafer Law Office offers a free consultation. A negligence per se attorney can compare the law, the police report, and your medical records to see how they fit together.

How Do a Police Report and a Traffic Ticket Fit In?

A police report and a traffic ticket can point to a broken law, but neither one settles your claim by itself. The report usually includes the officer’s notes, a diagram, witness names, and any citations. Photos of the scene, dash camera video, and witness phone numbers can back up what the report says. If the Kentucky State Police handled your crash, the steps for getting a copy are on the KSP collision report page. For crashes handled by Louisville Metro Police, you’d generally start with that department. Officers can take about 10 days to finish a report, so it may not be ready right away.

Insurance adjusters read these reports too. They work for companies regulated by the Kentucky Department of Insurance. Part of their job is to judge the claim for the company.

Mike Schafer worked on the insurance defense side before opening his own practice in 1990. He has seen a clear violation still leave room to argue about injuries. He has also presented a case review to the Kentucky Justice Association on one point: low property damage doesn’t mean no injury. Treatment records tend to carry that part of the claim. Keeping every record and photo in one folder from the first week can make things easier later.

How Does Shared Fault Affect a Negligence Per Se Claim?

A jury can assign a percentage of blame to each driver in a crash. Under KRS 411.182, jurors look at what each person did and how closely it connects to the harm. Kentucky follows a pure comparative fault rule. That generally means your damages are reduced by your own share of blame, not thrown out. If a jury found you 20 percent at fault for $100,000 in damages, your award would generally drop by $20,000.

Adjusters sometimes point to something the injured driver did, like braking late or glancing at a phone, to push that percentage higher. Even a small percentage can change the final number, so it helps to know how the other side may argue it. If a Louisville case reaches trial, a jury in Jefferson Circuit Court may decide it. The Kentucky Court of Justice site explains how those courts work. That’s one reason to speak with a Kentucky negligence per se attorney before you give a recorded statement.

Frequently Asked Questions About Car Accident Law

Does negligence per se mean the other driver is automatically responsible for my crash?

No, and it’s not meant to work that way. Federal courts applying Kentucky law have called it a tool that makes proving fault simpler. You’ll still need to link the broken law to your injuries and your losses, and gathering your medical records and photos early gives that link support.

What if the other driver wasn’t given a ticket?

A missing ticket doesn’t necessarily end the discussion. The question is whether a law was broken, not whether an officer wrote it up. The Kentucky State Police say an officer’s report can take about 10 days to finish, so the version you see on day two may be incomplete, and you can collect your own photos, witness names, and video in the meantime.

How long do I have to file a car accident claim in Kentucky?

Kentucky car accident injury lawsuits generally have to be filed within two years. That period comes from the Motor Vehicle Reparations Act. It can run from the injury date or from the last no-fault benefit payment, whichever is later. Since the dates can shift, you’ll want to check yours soon instead of waiting.

Can negligence per se apply to a truck accident?

It can, but the rule that was broken matters. Kentucky courts have generally applied negligence per se to state laws. Federal courts in Kentucky have turned away claims based only on federal trucking regulations, so if a truck was involved in your crash, a lawyer can check whether a Kentucky law or regulation also applies.

The Schafer Law Office: Your Car Accident Law Firm

If another driver broke a traffic law and you were hurt, you’re probably wondering if that matters for your claim, and it may.

Mike Schafer started as a prosecutor, spent time at an insurance defense firm, and has represented injured Kentuckians since 1990. He has seen how a broken traffic law gets argued from both sides (and how often the injury matters as much as the ticket).

The Schafer Law Office can go over your police report and medical records with you during a free consultation. Contact our firm today if you’d like to talk through where your claim may stand, and bring whatever paperwork you have.

Get Help Now

We are here for you. You are not alone

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Office Location

1218 S 3rd St
Louisville, KY 40203

Contact Us

502-584-9511

Copyright © 2026 The Schafer Law Office • All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer | Site Map | Privacy Policy. Digital Marketing By: rizeup media logo

*Images are obtained under license from Canva and other third-party stock image providers, with attribution included where required.

es_MXES